
mrblonde
I kind of agree with the Bring Back The Biff call.
When it's just two players, the refs should just let them embarrass themselves for a while. But: Penalise the third player in, to stop it becoming a brawl.
I can't see a way of "legislating" for more "razzle-dazzle", "Warriorball":
More points for a try starting from your own 20m. Too hard to judge how and when a movement starts.
More points for a try scored within 3 tackles. Maybe easier to judge, but who wants to go to the video ref every single try to confirm it, which you can bet would happen?
More point for a try full-stop might be the best idea. But then they'd probably make penalties worth more to compensate.
Let's just be greatful no-one's over-thought the 7 tackle/20m restart rule. The only thing wrong with that is I think 20m is punishment enough, an extra tackle is excessive. But imagine if there was a rule about "the defending team only gets a 7th tackle if the kick was from within the 30m line but still restart from the 20m line", "It's only a restart from 20m if it goes over the dead-ball line" etc...
When it's just two players, the refs should just let them embarrass themselves for a while. But: Penalise the third player in, to stop it becoming a brawl.
I can't see a way of "legislating" for more "razzle-dazzle", "Warriorball":
More points for a try starting from your own 20m. Too hard to judge how and when a movement starts.
More points for a try scored within 3 tackles. Maybe easier to judge, but who wants to go to the video ref every single try to confirm it, which you can bet would happen?
More point for a try full-stop might be the best idea. But then they'd probably make penalties worth more to compensate.
Let's just be greatful no-one's over-thought the 7 tackle/20m restart rule. The only thing wrong with that is I think 20m is punishment enough, an extra tackle is excessive. But imagine if there was a rule about "the defending team only gets a 7th tackle if the kick was from within the 30m line but still restart from the 20m line", "It's only a restart from 20m if it goes over the dead-ball line" etc...