I’ve been thinking about this during the first half and it’s a tough one because Reynolds has sorta got better as he’s gone on where as Shaun Johnson peaked early (or did he?) that season before he broke his leg he was unbelievable, while dce has been the most consistent- won a gf in his debut year (beating Shaun Johnson) and is still going strong.Who has the best halfback out of our clubs? Have to be Reynolds wouldn't it? Or is there a case for DCE? Shaun Johnson too hot and cold I reckon but his defence might be the best of the three
So I would say…
On recent form (the last couple of years) Reynolds, dce, Shaun Johnson.
In their prime Shaun Johnson, dce, Reynolds.
Over the course of their career dce, Shaun Johnson, Reynolds.