Game Information



01 Jan 1970 12:00PM

# Player Player #

Status
Not open for further replies.

Toookey

1st Grade Fringe
May 3, 2021
698
Murchie 2021:
4 games - 4 errors, tackles at 60.3%, 1 ruck infringement, 2 offloads & averages 54m.

Katoa has got to be the more likely one to come into the side
Not too sure where you’re getting your stats from Cces, but that’s not the case for Murchie. In 4 games he’s made 115 tackles and missed 9. I don’t know stats well but that’s no where near 60%. Has also made about 325 meters in those games so is up over 80m per game.

Thats from footystatistics.com which is what they base fantasy NRL from so I hope their fairly accurate
 

jonesy101

1st Grade Fringe
Aug 28, 2016
1,113
Not too sure where you’re getting your stats from Cces, but that’s not the case for Murchie. In 4 games he’s made 115 tackles and missed 9. I don’t know stats well but that’s no where near 60%. Has also made about 325 meters in those games so is up over 80m per game.

Thats from footystatistics.com which is what they base fantasy NRL from so I hope their fairly accurate
Its what it says on his official NRL profile currently but its hugely wrong. I think at his worst he had an 83% tackle efficiency in the game against the Storm, otherwise he's been around 90% or better per game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: wizards rage

Spudwebb

U20's Player
May 10, 2021
42
Zero interest in watching this team play. I know Brown thinks he’s REALLY clever with the game day switcharoo but the only people he’s upsetting are fantasy players.

With injuries it is what it is. But I’m not planning on watching if Kosi plays. Nothing against him personally, but I don’t want watch a rookie propwing team up with a veteran propwing to cost us another game.

Evans STILL starting is an extremely poor message to the rest of the team after his defence cost us two tries.

Presumably Walsh starts since SuperCoach said he made a mistake benching him this week. But who knows. Something like this might be interesting. Although Chanel Harris-Tavita’s kicking was miserable again and I’m becoming more and more convinced he should be the one that moves to hooker.

6. Walsh
7. Chanel Harris-Tavita
9. Nikorima
14 Egan
Unfortunately Evans wasn't on the field for the first 24mins, of the 2nd half, when the club Leaked 26 points in 24mins. If you want to single out players, watch that 24mins of embarrassment. As far as I'm concern, we the Warriors we need to build combinations to help the Team between rookies & senior to develop a Winning culture.....Not bagging individuals.
 

Cces

1st Grade Fringe
Aug 12, 2013
646
Christchurch
Not too sure where you’re getting your stats from Cces, but that’s not the case for Murchie. In 4 games he’s made 115 tackles and missed 9. I don’t know stats well but that’s no where near 60%. Has also made about 325 meters in those games so is up over 80m per game.

Thats from footystatistics.com which is what they base fantasy NRL from so I hope their fairly accurate
They're from NRL.com & there's a big discrepancy isn't there? If think with the metres they've included the games he's been 18th man in there division. With the tackle % they also factor in ineffective tackles (which he has 5) which other sites might not consider but even so that stat is way off too.
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20210511-214525_DuckDuckGo.jpg
    Screenshot_20210511-214525_DuckDuckGo.jpg
    260.6 KB · Views: 12
  • Like
Reactions: Toookey

Tony Martin

1st Grade Fringe
Jun 4, 2016
974
Hiku actually always had the odd strong and aggressive defensive game. Without seeing them strung together I wouldn't out my money on turning a corner
He does come up with the rare strong defensive game. Someone could put together a highlights reel and push the argument he is a strong defender. Unfortunately I don’t think the clip would be longer than 8 seconds
 

Swanley

Warriors 1st Grader
Apr 13, 2012
3,128
Tonbridge, Kent, UK
It’s good to have experienced depth but this isn’t a huge blow in my opinion. Our biggest weakness right now is edge defence.

There’s no way Hiku could be selected ahead of Pompey or Aitken. They are both miles better.

I actually prefer Berry over Hiku also. And if Vailea continues playing like he did on the weekend, then his first grade development becomes more important than Hiku as a fourth string centre.

Hopefully we can buy out Hiku and Turner to clear the roster spots.
Turner? He's left
Hiku? He's the best attacking Centre we have, I like Pompey, but currently I only see him as upgrade on Kata, does not seem to pass the ball often, but is a good defender. Hiku should get selected ahead of Pompey, who could potentially replace Ken or Ed on the wing.
 

TheCool

1st Grade Fringe
Jul 18, 2013
2,029
Turner? He's left
Hiku? He's the best attacking Centre we have, I like Pompey, but currently I only see him as upgrade on Kata, does not seem to pass the ball often, but is a good defender. Hiku should get selected ahead of Pompey, who could potentially replace Ken or Ed on the wing.
Turner hasn’t left yet. Pompey has well and truly gone past Hiku. Was one of our best against Cows last week and was good again against Manly. Kata comparison is a terrible call.
 

TheSultan

1st Grade Fringe
Apr 19, 2018
114
Isn't Turner injured for the rest of the season?

What makes you think Pompey is better than a fully fit Hiku?
I like Pompey better than Kata solely on the basis that he hasnt ever ‘dashed’ out of dummy half on the last tackle and been held up over the line. May of worked a couple of times but damn it was frustrating how blatantly he was telegraphing those plays near the end of his stint with us
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Last Game

27 Aug

16 - 28
5.6 Total Avg Rating
0.0 Your Avg Rating

Highest Rated Player

Lowest Rated Player

Compiled from 5 ratings