I've dragged the data together from the Rugby League Project site for a previous season. I mentioned it in the Blake Ayshford thread somewhere. This season's stats were mentioned by the SKY team on the After Match in Sunday evening.
No disrespect to you here at all - but I think the Sky Team might well have it wrong... because 2 of our top 3 try scorers this season (top three being Kata,
Shaun Johnson, Ayshford) play on the right edge and have done so all season. Not to mention I think the right edge back rower and the right winger (whoever it was) have all scored tries as well. I think our right edge has outscored our left edge this season in total tries (Robson/Leuluai haven't scored many, Hoffman hasn't scored many, Kata has 8, the left winger (be it Manu/Wright etc) has a few. And I think defensively our left edge has conceded more.
Damn it, now I'm going to have to go and figure it all out! The stat just doesn't make sense (logically) on a tries for/against basis.
Edit (this is going to take some time, but I'll update it as I can)
Round 1: Against the tigers:
Left edge - scored 2 (Kata). Right edge - scored 2 (
Shaun Johnson and Thompson 1 each).
Conceded: Left edge 4, (
Sironen, Nofoaluma, Tedesco, Simona). Right edge 1 (Lovett). Middle 1 (Tedesco in the 80th minute). Simona's try is arguably not conceded by the left edge as he scored under the posts. But the initial break was made down the left edge so I have put it in.
After Round 1: Left edge is -2 (tries scored/against), right edge is +1.
Round 2: Broncos:
Conceded: Right edge 2 (Oates, Reed), left edge 2 (Boyd, Gillett)
Neither edge scored (Luke was the only try-scorer in the middle).
Both edges -2.
Cumulative Left edge -4, Right edge -1.
Round 3: Storm
Left edge - scored Kata and Wright, conceded Munster
Right edge - scored Lolohea, conceded Koroibete.
Left +1, Right 0.
Cumulative: Left -3, Right edge -1.
Round 4: Knights
Left: Scored Kata and Manu, conceded Gagai
Right: Scored Ayshford, Lolohea,
Shaun Johnson, conceded Ross
Left +1, Right +2
Cumulative: Left -2, Right +1
Round 5: Roosters
Left: Scored Manu, Kata 2,
Shaun Johnson 1 (yes on the left) Conceded SKD 2, Aubusson 1
Right: Scored
Shaun Johnson,
Roger Tuivasa-Sheck (the break came on the right side) Conceded Taukeiaho
Left +1, Right +1
Cumulative: Left edge -1, Right edge +2
Round 6: Manly
Left: Scored Kata Conceded Trbojevic
Right: Scored Ayshford Conceded Taupau (Manly scored 3 tries in the middle)
Left 0, Right 0
Cumulative: Left edge -1, Right edge +2
Round 7: Bulldogs
Left: Scored Wright, Lolohea Conceded Perrett 2, Holland 2
Right: Scored Ayshford 2, Fusitua 1 Conceded None.
Left -2, Right +3
Cumulative: Left edge -3, Right edge +5
Round 8: Storm
Left: Scored 0 Conceded Munster, Cronk, Vunivalu 2
Right: Scored 0 Conceded
Harris, Glasby (half blame should go to the middle, but I'll count it here), Koroibete
Left -4, Right -3
Cumulative: Left edge -7, Right edge +2
Round 9: Dragons
Left: Scored Allwood Conceded Faifailoa
Right: Scored
Shaun Johnson Conceded Aitken
(Gubb and Robson both scored in the middle)
Left 0, Right 0
Cumulative: Left edge -7, Right edge +2
Round 10: Panthers
Left: Scored Kata, Wright Conceded
Dallin Watene-Zelezniak
Right: Scored Ayshford Conceded Soward, Peachey 3 (although 1 of those came from a break down the left edge)
Left +1, Right -3
Cumulative: Left edge -6, Right edge -1
Round 11: Raiders
Left: Scored 0 Conceded Austin, Leilua
Right: Scored
Shaun Johnson, Ayshford (Thompson and Ayshford butchered 2 more) Conceded Croker, Papalii, Lee
Left -2, Right -1
Cumulative: Left edge -8, Right edge -2
Summary:
Left Edge: Scored: 16 Conceded: 24 for -8 overall
Right Edge: Scored: 16 Conceded: 18 for -2 overall
So yep, would have to say I completely disagree with the Sky Sports team in saying our right edge is the worst in the competition. Given that our left edge is significantly worse than our right! (and yes, I've just spent too much time reviewing highlights on youtube and scoring charts). Included in the right side's conceded stats are 2 questionable ones as well, being Peachey's last try in the panthers game where the defence was shot to shit because they broke down our left, the line slide across and they then had an overlap on the right; and the Glasby one in the storm game where he scored between the middle and the edge (was tough for me to make a call on whether to include it or not so I did).