Aaron Lester: Why I quit Haven
23rd September 2010
Ex Whitehaven player Aaron Lester and wife Clare with children Emily Zach and Jake at their Moresby home
THERE may have been better rugby league players than Aaron Lester to wear the chocolate blue and gold but not too many.
That’s why within a relatively short time of making his majestic mark at Whitehaven the former New Zealand junior international was selected for The Immortals - 13 players judged to be Haven’s all-time greats in their respective positions. In the eyes of many good judges the teak-tough Kiwi had the ability to play full Test rugby for New Zealand alongside such early contemporaries as Stacey Jones – certainly good enough to hold his own in Super League had he chosen to leave the Recre.
But instead, for the best part of a decade, Aaron Lester was Whitehaven’s own Man of Steel, captaining the side in two successive Championship Grand Finals and amid rapturous Recre scenes collected a piece of long-awaited silverware as League leaders.
When Lester played well the Whitehaven team generally played well, he led inspiringly from the front.
Now, as the curtain comes down on 62 years of Recreation Ground history, the team’s acknowledged talisman reflects on a distinguished career.
In the first of a two-part feature, Aaron also talks candidly about his Haven ups and downs and for the first time publicly reveals the reasons for his shock decision to quit the club.
Lester served under no fewer than six Whitehaven coaches – Stan Martin, Colin (“Buck”) Armstrong briefly as player/coach, Kevin Tamati, Paul Cullen, Steve McCormack and, more controversially, Dave Rotheram.
Paul Crarey and Ged Stokes both tried to entice him back but to no avail.
Not the sweetest of endings but the Lester individual brilliance and leadership will remain forever in Whitehaven RLFC’s history books – not bad for a relatively unknown lad who arrived, unheralded, into a cold, dark West Cumbrian town from the Land of the Long White Cloud.
Stan Martin was the magnet not only for Aaron but also a galaxy of bright young Kiwi talent – David Fatialofa, Leroy Joe, Siose Muliumu and Gus Malietoa-Brown.
Stan Martin had succeeded an even more illustrious New Zealander (Kurt Sorensen) as Whitehaven coach. Stan was a great mentor, getting the best out of the fledgling Kiwis as well as some excellent local talent.
Stan, as with the case of Lester, Fats and Joe was to leave a legacy of his own.
But overall his permanent replacement, fellow countryman Kevin Tamati, was unable to leave the same impression.
Lester is frank in his view: “I am not being disrespectful to Kevin but he was a better player (ex Widnes and New Zealand Test front rower) than he was a coach. For me, personally, coaching wise he was struggling.”
Next it was Paul Cullen, bringing in culture changes on and off the field.
“Before Paul came, all sorts was going on,” says Lester. He disclosed: “I had talks with Ralph Calvin – potentially I was going to be player/coach but I was never really going to do it so young.
“Whitehaven suited Paul Cullen and Paul Cullen suited Whitehaven.
“During Kevin Tamati’s time we were struggling, good young players like Phil Sherwen and the Purdham boys, Rob and Garry. I had a lot of respect for all of them but they were chucked in at the deep end. We always had the players, but never enough of them.
“Under Steve McCormack the club attracted some excellent overseas players alongside some excellent local talent. Our worst player in the team was better than what we had two years before!”
It culminated in the euphoria of two Champion-ship Grand Finals.
Says Aaron: “The first (against Leigh) went into extra time, but we should have won. I was more demoralised the year after when we lost to Castleford.”
Bouncing back from being 18-0 down to beat Castleford (at The Recre) a couple of weeks before might have given Haven a huge confidence boost for the final but Lester points out: “In some ways it was worse; but when it got to the final itself we just didn’t perform.
“There were a lot of rumours that we didn’t want to win, that we didn’t want to go into Super League. I can assure you everybody wanted to win both those finals, it would have been good for us as players and also for the town to have the big clubs come to Whitehaven.”
Were you over-awed against Cas? – “No, we just didn’t perform. With all the promotional stuff our coach had to do in the week leading up to the final, our preparation wasn’t all that good.
“We didn’t train at our normal times, everything was unsettled, Castleford just came out on fire, we didn’t. Cas were a really good team, perhaps we didn’t fully appreciate they were full time and we were part-timers.
“When we lost the previous season I don’t think you could possibly lose any better. Everybody gave it their all.”
Next chapter: Steve McCormack lured away to Widnes and Dave Rotheram arrives from St Helens.
AD
“Dave came in with some new ideas, some of his drills I really enjoyed. For me it was a little bit of fresh air, I was full of enthusiasm.”
So much so that Lester led Haven again to the Championship play-offs but it proved all bitter sweet. The pain was not down to a broken arm alone.
“When I broke my arm, the club brought in Aaron Smith, there was an influx of travelling players,” he explained.
“I was retiring at the end of my contract, I’d already said (to Dave) that we needed to give Matty (Graeme Mattinson) as much chance to develop as hooker. I saw him as my replacement along with Sicey (Carl Sice) who was the best bench player in the league. Dave didn’t really see it that way, his idea was that they should try and take that position off me.
“I started the season as hooker and when I broke my arm it seemed bad for me but good for Matty and Sicey. Then the club went and signed Aaron Smith. I was disappointed. I thought ‘what’s the point of that....money wasted. Aaron Smith’s a good player but was he better than what we’ve got?’ I didn’t think he was. That was sort of the beginning of the end for me.
“I didn’t feel as though I was playing that badly, if I was comparing myself to the rest of the team. Was I below par? – no I don’t think so.”
Were you spitting the dummy out? – “Was I? Maybe a little bit yeah. When I signed my last contract I decided I didn’t want to stand in the way of youth but there were a couple of other issues going on that I wasn’t liking.
“Dave was a good coach but if I’ve got a criticism it was his man management. A few players were disgruntled.
“The game I got dropped for was the semi-final of the Northern Rail Cup – I was about to go training and Dave came up and said ‘you’re not playing’.
“I was the club captain but I wasn’t told until that morning, I was dropped – not even in the 17 but Dave said ‘I want you before the game to get in among the changing room and at half time’.
“I said ‘I’m not doing that’ – Dave didn’t have the decency to tell me earlier on in the week so I just said ‘no’.
“Don’t get me wrong, I would love to have finished the year playing for Whitehaven. I had a couple of days away from the club, had a discussion with Dave, sounded him out about a few things but still didn’t like what I was hearing.
“Our relationship had broken down.”
Clare, your wife, was heart-broken about the way you hung up your boots – “Yeah, I don’t think she necessarily agreed with the way I finished. Clare always supported me, although she’d twine a bit about the time I would give to the game. We didn’t get married for three years because I was playing, we were engaged but I wasn’t having a weekend off to get married! Selfishly sometimes my rugby league came before my family. Clare was upset, she wasn’t happy but she also understood the situation.”
Did anyone extend the olive branch after Dave’s departure? “Yes Paul Crarey did (the next coach) and then Ged (Stokes); they asked me to go back and play. I said I’d consider but other issues needed sorted out first.
“Basically when I retired I left halfway through a season, I’d rung Des Byrne (then club chairman) and said ‘that’s me finished’, we’d need to sort something out contractually.
“I gave back my sponsored car to Ron Batty. I hadn’t been paid for the first four months of the year; as soon as I retired I relinquished the rest of my contract, a clean break.
“A lot of other sportsmen don’t quit like I did; they get sacked and get their money.
“Ged said ‘we’ll sort it out and you’ll get you outstanding money paid monthly’ but I didn’t get a phone call, it didn’t happen.
“Whitehaven were very good for me for nine and a half years. In the last half a year I was a professional right up to day I left, but I don’t think the club conducted themselves professionally towards me – that’s the way it goes.
“I have no regrets, the only regret is that I didn’t finish the year playing the game and saying ‘so long’ on the field to the likes of Leroy, Fats and Seedsey. I had a choice to make, I made that choice.”
THERE may have been better rugby league players than Aaron Lester to wear the chocolate blue and gold but not too many.
www.whitehavennews.co.uk